Jurate Macnoriute
Stylistic
Differences of Mentally Ill and Far East Artists. Character of Openness as
One From Two Supreme Criterions Diagnosing Mental Illness
Because Eastern art is notable for its perfect manipulation with line and because linear solution is also characteristic for mentally ill people, I decided to compare lines behavior in both practices. For that purpose I chose a Chinese page printed in copper movable type in 1726 and E. Munch's landscape "Am Strom"; other two samples: Ando Hiroshige, "Plum Estate", and van Gogh's copy of this same print in oil "Flowering Plum Tree".
![]() The page from Qinding gujin tushu jicheng, Kangxi Qing Dynasty (1726) Lines alive and form close system for viewer's glance: they arise from the left lower corner to top and to the right side and fall together with the upper rabbit, along pin's stem viewer's glance goes to the lower rabbit and returns again to the stem.
|
E. Munch, Am Strom, 1908, Oil on canvas, 62.5 x 49.5 cm Lines alive, but do not form any close system for viewer's glance, because space is open and lines run outwards without any sign of return. |
|
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Ando Hiroshige, Plum Estate, Kameido, 1857, From "One Hundred Famous Views of Edo"; Woodblock print, 13 1/4 x 8 5/8 in. Hiroshige's tree has volume. Space deep, three dimensions appreciable. Impression of airiness. Euphoric mood. Serenity. Viewer's glance slips throughout surface. Hiroshige's space is open, but he does not emphatically separates any object, in contrary he places on the left pure red rectangle with hieroglyphs for creation a diversion of centre.
|
V. van Gogh, Flowering Plum Tree (after Hiroshige), Oil on canvas, 55 x 46 cm, Paris, September-October, 1887.V. van Gogh's tree plane without materiality. Space is not deep, similar to two dimensional. Impression of tightness. Earth is this same near and far. Far trees and human figures are inversed and without shades. Far light converted to blossom. Less precision, but this feature is conditioned by oil technique's differences from print. V. van Gogh's space of "Flowering Plum Tree" is closed by formal sidelong strips with hieroglyphs and concentration on centre, but together this closeness remains problematic. Coloring changed to warmer. Conversion from one color to another sudden. Absence of euphoria. Viewer's glance anxiously rooted to the geometric centre of picture.
|
This research shows that simple openness or closeness does not form mentally ill or healthy attitude. Only pointed contrast between openness of picture space with emphasis on central part shows absence of unity and it is one of main symptoms of mental illness.
All articles
Introduction to Art of Mentally Ill and Healthy People
Mental Illnesses. Short Review
Art Testing for Mentally Ill and Mentally Healthy People
Stylistic Characteristics of Art of Mentally Ill Patients and Mentally Healthy People
Anti-weight of Depicted Objects as One From Two Supreme Criterions Diagnosing Mental Illness
The Drawing Test for Individuals Suffering Mental Illness
The Drawing Test for People not Diagnosed With Mental Illness
Diagnostic Example. Self Analysis
Stylistic Closeness Between Mentally Ill and Gothic Arts
Stylistic Characteristics of Criminals Art
Art Styles, Directions, Movements and Mental Illnesses
Presence of Time in Painting of Mentally Ill and Mentally Healthy Artists
Conclusive Result of Research on Art of Mentally Ill and Healthy Artists
Copyright © 2004, Jurate Macnoriute
Sponsored Links |